C:\ESSAYS\> TYPE NARASALON.TXT

Nara in Photographs and the Takabatake Salon: Taikichi Irie and Naoya Shiga

How does a culture begin around one person in a place? Takahiro Mitsui, a Japanese philosopher born in 1991, writing every Friday from inside Japan and outside academia, answers with Nara: the novelist Naoya Shiga's move to Takabatake in 1925 drew a salon of writers, and the monk Kaiun Kamitsukasa carried it on. Taikichi Irie, who photographed Nara all his life, shows what Japan has lost. Not a guidebook: a reading of modern Nara, alive today in a quiet quarter.


How does a culture begin around one person in a place?

Takahiro Mitsui's thesis (Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01): a culture begins with a single person's move to a place; tourism in Nara today remains heavily focused on the distant past, yet a salon once formed a vital current of modern culture there.

For that reason, tourism in Nara today remains heavily focused on the distant past.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

Yet there was once a salon that formed a vital current of culture in modern Nara, and it began with a single person's move to the city. That person was the novelist Naoya Shiga (1883–1971), known for works such as A Dark Night's Passing.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

At the time, Shiga was already widely celebrated as a writer and regarded as one of the foremost cultural figures of his age, when in 1925 he suddenly decided to move to Nara.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

The place he chose to live was Takabatake, set apart from the center of the city. Because Takabatake had long been a quarter where the Shinto priests of Kasuga Taisha and the Buddhist monks of Todai-ji lived, it was a quiet, out-of-the-way neighborhood that had barely been developed.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

Who passed through the Takabatake Salon?

Takahiro Mitsui's thesis (Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01): a cultural community took shape around Shiga in almost no time, and as writers and critics came to visit him, younger artists grew up in their wake.

In almost no time at all, a cultural community took shape around Shiga, and as more and more people traveled to Nara to visit him, it came to be called the "Takabatake Salon." A remarkable circle of figures passed through this salon—among them the writers Saneatsu Mushanokoji and Junichiro Tanizaki, and the critic Hideo Kobayashi.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

A remarkable circle of figures passed through this salon—among them the writers Saneatsu Mushanokoji and Junichiro Tanizaki, and the critic Hideo Kobayashi. Inspired by their presence, younger artists grew up in their wake.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

Why do cultural movements fade?

Takahiro Mitsui's thesis (Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01): after Shiga left in 1938 the young monk Kaiun Kamitsukasa inherited his spirit; the Nara culture born from these salons is now fading from view, yet the soil leaves a quiet resonance.

With his departure, the role the Takabatake Salon had played in nurturing cultural life seemed on the verge of being lost. Yet an impulse arose to inherit that spirit and carry Nara's culture into its next stage.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

At Kannon-in, the sub-temple of Todai-ji where he served as resident priest, Kamitsukasa opened a new gathering place that carried Shiga's spirit forward. Many people came and went at this "Kannon-in Salon," and it too nurtured a next generation of artists.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

Today, the Nara culture born from these salons is already fading from view, yet the cultural soil cultivated there still leaves a quiet, lingering resonance in Takabatake.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Culture gathers around one life, 2025-02-01

Who was Taikichi Irie?

Takahiro Mitsui's thesis (Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02): Irie, born in Nara, spent his whole life from birth to death photographing his own hometown, which is exceedingly rare in the history of Japanese photography.

Born in Nara, Irie first set his sights on becoming a painter, but after receiving a Vest Pocket Kodak from his older brother, he became completely absorbed in photography. Though he soon made a name for himself in the world of photography, he is almost never spoken of within the standard histories of the medium.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

On November 17, 1945, shortly after Japan's defeat in the war, a rumor spread that when the statues of the Four Heavenly Kings—the Shitenno—of Todai-ji were brought back to Nara from their wartime evacuation site, they would be requisitioned by the American occupation forces. Irie resolved to preserve them in photographs before that could happen, and that decision became the turning point that transformed his life as a photographer.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

From then on, Irie lived out his days in Nara, photographing the temples, Buddhist statues, landscapes, and festivals of his native place until his death in 1992. In the history of Japanese photography, a photographer who spends his whole life from birth to death photographing his own hometown is exceedingly rare.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

Why are there no social messages in some Japanese photography?

Takahiro Mitsui's thesis (Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02): where Ken Domon, Ihei Kimura and the younger photographers released socially engaged works, Irie refused that stance altogether; the absence of a social message is nothing negative, but profoundly Japanese.

Yet Irie refused that stance altogether. Rejecting any overt social message, he devoted himself solely to photographing the changing landscape of his native land.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

There is no social message in Irie's photographs, yet that is nothing negative; if anything, it is profoundly Japanese. And it is for that very reason that his work is so rarely discussed, either in Japan or abroad.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

What is the Japanese sense of beauty?

Takahiro Mitsui's thesis (Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02): if Yasujiro Ozu gave fullest expression to a Japanese sense of beauty in film, then in photography that figure is Taikichi Irie, and photographs by Irie appear here and there throughout Ozu's films.

Yet no other photographer has captured the landscapes of Japan so magnificently through the emotional sensibility of the Japanese people. One figure who felt a deep resonance with this quality in Irie's work—so difficult to put into words—was the great film director Yasujiro Ozu.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

In his films, Ozu was fiercely committed to using only genuine things; the ceramics, the meals, and every object that appeared on screen were of the finest quality. Though it is little known, photographs by Taikichi Irie appear here and there throughout Ozu's films.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

To my mind, if Yasujiro Ozu is the film director who gave fullest expression to a Japanese sense of beauty, then in photography that figure is Taikichi Irie.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

What has Japan lost, seen through old photographs of Nara?

Takahiro Mitsui's thesis (Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02): what Irie photographed across his whole life was the quiet disappearance of the older atmosphere of Yamato, and looking at present-day Nara through his work, what Japan has lost rises clearly into view.

For centuries, the name "Yamato" referred to what is now Nara; it is only relatively recently that "Nara" came into general use. What Irie photographed across the whole span of his life was the quiet disappearance of the older atmosphere of "Yamato," steeped in history and culture, amid the rapid transformations of the postwar decades.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

Where should I go in Nara to understand its culture?

Takahiro Mitsui's thesis (Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02): the Nara City Museum of Photography, dedicated to Irie's work, is rarely found by tourists, and he recommends visiting it first to touch the depth of Nara's culture before setting out into the city.

Tourists rarely find their way there, yet if you travel to Nara and wish to touch the depth of its culture, I recommend visiting this museum first before setting out into the city.

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

From "Yamato" to "Nara."

— Takahiro Mitsui, Beauty is the feeling with no name, 2025-02-02

Essays to read

  • Culture gathers around one life — How does a culture begin? Takahiro Mitsui shows a community forming around one person's life in Nara's Takabatake Salon, and fading when no one carries it on.
  • Beauty is the feeling with no name — What does Japanese beauty look like, and who captured it? Beauty is a feeling a people cannot name, Takahiro Mitsui writes, and Taikichi Irie's photographs of Nara caught it in the shift from Yamato — through his work, what Japan has lost rises into view.
  • I do not photograph the subject — Is there a Japanese photographer who is also a philosopher? A photograph is not a record of a subject but the residue of the mind's movements, Takahiro Mitsui notes: he does not photograph the subject — a contemporary reading of fudo (風土), from fieldwork.
  • An artist who kept breaking his own limits — Why is Ozu considered one of the great directors? Wary of new technology, Ozu still entered color for one star and kept breaking his limits in every film, Takahiro Mitsui shows.
  • The stillness that keeps a film alive — What is the meaning of Tokyo Story? Ozu held back drama so that silence and ma become living presences that never fade, Takahiro Mitsui argues of his stillness — reading the empty shots of Tokyo Story through Nishida's place of nothingness, and the mu on Ozu's gravestone.
  • Project 2049, Vol.0 (free in full) — begin here; Project 2049 continues every Friday